Click the logo to listen to Jack & Tracey give a bombshell interview to George Knapp on Coast to Coast AM on January 26th, 2026 where they reveal new information regarding the kidnapper of the real Paul Fronczak.

The search for truth continues.

This season of

The Fronczak Files: The Making Of Monsters

takes a deeper, more revealing turn. Jack Fronczak and Tracey Hastings explore Jack’s genealogy, complex cultural and ethnic roots, and the dysfunctional family dynamics he was born into in 1963 — forces that ultimately led to his abandonment and the disappearance of his twin sister, Jill Rosenthal, in 1965.

Season Three pulls back the curtain on the secrets, contradictions, and long-buried lies at the heart of Jack’s story.

It examines how identity is shaped not only by DNA and documents, but by trauma, history, and unanswered questions.

Despite everything, Jack remains determined to find his sister and understand who he truly is — beyond names, files, and official records.

Join us for a season that challenges what we think we know about identity, family, and truth and proves that some mysteries are far from over.

Season 3

The Fronczak Files

The Making of Monsters

Premieres Feb. 10, 2026

Meet The Hosts

Paul Jack Fronczak is best known for being at the center of one of the most complex identity mysteries in American history. Raised as the infant kidnapped from a Chicago hospital in 1964, Jack later learned through DNA that he was not biologically related to the Fronczak family — a revelation that transformed his life and redefined his understanding of who he was.

Rather than turning away from the truth, Jack pursued it.

His search for identity led him across continents, into archives and family histories, and ultimately into his own origins. Along the way, he became an advocate for those living with unanswered questions about who they are and where they come from. His books, The Foundling and True Identity, and the Emmy-nominated documentary The Lost Sons brought his story to a global audience and reshaped how modern identity cases are understood.

Today, as founder, host, and executive producer of The Fronczak Files, Jack combines lived experience with investigative rigor, compassion, and persistence. He understands that identity is more than DNA — it is memory, culture, loss, and resilience.

Jack’s mission is not only to uncover what was taken — but to help others reclaim what was never truly lost: their truth.

Founder, Host + Executive Producer

Tracey Hastings, RNC-OB

Co-Host, Genetic Genealogist + Associate Producer

Tracey Hastings brings a rare balance of scientific precision and human compassion to every investigation she leads. A registered nurse specializing in high-risk obstetrics, Tracey has spent her career working in moments where lives, identities, and outcomes can change in an instant — a perspective that naturally translated into her work in investigative research.

As co-host and associate producer of The Fronczak Files, Tracey is known for her meticulous attention to detail, relentless follow-through, and ability to see connections others miss. She approaches each case with both analytical discipline and deep empathy, ensuring that every story is treated with respect, dignity, and care.

Tracey’s partnership with Jack Fronczak began one short year ago, in January 2025 and has quickly evolved into a shared mission: to challenge assumptions, uncover buried truths, and give a voice to those lost in the margins of history.

Whether navigating complex records or guiding families through emotional discoveries, Tracey remains driven by one belief — that every person deserves to know where they come from, and every story deserves to be heard.